Vegan-friendly
Lacto
Ovo
Beer/Wine
Delivery
Take-out
Non-veg

Serves meat, vegan options available. About half of the menu is vegetarian, including mockchicken, black bean dishes, veganrib sandwich, tofu scramble, vegan pies, etc. Veganaise available on sandwiches upon request. Braille menu available for customers with vision impairments. Open Mon-Thu 7:00am-9:00pm, Fri 7:00am-10:00pm, Sat 7:30am-10:00pm, Sun 7:30am-9:00pm.


74 Reviews

First Review by rccourtney

JuliaLee

Points +106

Vegetarian
08 Nov 2026

Delicious Vegan Menu

We had the Tofu Scrambler, and it was delicious! I appreciate that they have a whole vegan menu, including pies, brownies, ice cream, and shakes.

Pros: Quality, Options, Price

thevilangel

Points +333

Vegan
17 Sep 2026

comfort vegan

after 6 years, it’s about time i review one of Madison’s vegan gems. 💎 i’ve been to Monty’s countless times, and tried nearly everything. It’s one of those places you can always rely on if something doesn’t work out or you’re unsure where to go. beautiful diner, kind staff, amazing food, fair prices/portions. nice parking lot for being Madison aswell. the sheldon is my absolute favorite option. it’s so so good every time. same with the shoplifters delight. pancakes and french toast are awesome, same with the fruit pies. they’ve won awards with them for reasons. the breakfast burrito is maybe the only thing that hasn’t wowed me. i only ordered it once tho. VEGAN SHAKES! they’re incredible. i ordered the chocolate covered strawberry last, and they just do so well at replicating that shake malt flavor. you can ask for vegan creamer and other sides. they’re very accommodating knowing they have a large vegan menu. i will return here for a long time 💙 (you’d think i’d have more photos 😅)

Updated from previous review on 2026-09-17

Pros: food, diner experience, portions

ashwickety

Points +138

Vegan
31 Aug 2026

Delicious!

I was here on a busy Sunday afternoon but was lucky to get a table right away:) A friend and I split the breakfast burrito and the French toast with Door County cherries - both were excellent, especially the burrito! They were filling & reasonably prices too. As a bonus, Level 5 donuts, an all vegan spot, was right across the street!

Pros: Food, Atmosphere

Rebacke

Points +2971

Vegan
08 Jun 2026

Lots of great option - even protein ones

Im so happy that I was able to stop here and get some vegan 🌱 options to choose from that even included Tempeh as protein!
I had the sandwich with mushrooms, 🍄‍🟫 tempeh, avocado 🥑 and cheese 🧀 and it was delicious.
The coleslaw was bland but I was happy it came as a side.
I really wanted to try the strawberry 🍓 rhubarb pie 🥧 but they were out.
But having a place where I could order different pie flavors, ice cream 🍦 and shakes is amazing.

Updated from previous review on 2026-06-08

Pros: Lots of option , Having tempeh as protein , Ice cream and dessert 🍨 options

acovertrawfoodqueen

Points +47

Vegan
22 Feb 2026

Vegan Med Bowl

VEGAN MED SALAD
Three crispy herb falafel on a bed of fresh greens with cucumbers, cherry tomatoes, mint, cilantro, and lemon-quinoa tabbouleh, tossed in a creamy avocado dressing and served with a dollop of hummus. Make it a wrap with a side (2.49).
$14.49
vegan

Updated from previous review on 2026-02-22

Pros: Herb Falafel , Humus, Spring Mix Greens, Cucumbers & Grape Tomatoes

Cons: None

mantabee

Points +221

Vegan
27 Nov 2025

Lots of options!

A clearly labeled dedicated vegan section for meals and dessert. I had the Sheldon and it was good but nothing too special. Enjoyed the vegan milkshake

meredithparker

Points +158

Vegan
22 Oct 2025

Average, just average

The vegan sandwiches were delicious. Everything else was mediocre or bland.

We noticed was there were two different menus on the table. One menu had a significantly larger vegan menu than the other two. When we asked about it, the server said that that menu was not supposed to be out because it wasn't current. This one menu was the menu on their website too so their website is wrong if that's true.

As I said, the sandwiches were delicious. The vegan chocolate covered strawberry shake was also delicious.

Everything else was not.

-the fries were soft/mushy and kind of cold (not salted well either)
-vegan coleslaw was bland
-vegan pancakes were mushy and just not good (the banana in the middle just turned them into mush)

Overall, pretty disappointing. I would not return if I had a choice. 3 stars because the sandwiches were good, but everything else was not.

Pros: Heathen Vegan Shoplifter's Delight, Sheldon, Vegan chocolate covered strawberry shake

Cons: Vegan coleslaw, Fries, Pancakes

erinthomp

Points +1302

Vegan
14 Sep 2025

Great sandwiches!

Delicious lunch (or breakfast) spot with great sandwiches! The fries are also perfectly salty.

chknarcane

Points +303

Vegan
19 Jul 2025

Lots of variety, dedicated vegan menu

This restaurant has a very clearly labeled vegan section of their menu with several breakfast options (served all day), several lunch/dinner options, and decadent dessert options like shakes, pies, and sundaes. Our whole group was happy with everything.

Pros: Large vegan menu, Breakfast all day, Lots of dessert options

LunaMaya9

Points +96

Herbivore
16 Mar 2025

Maybe breakfast is better?

We always ordered lunch or dinner. My partner loved this place when he ate meat so I tried a lot of their veg meals when he ordered and was never impressed (flavor, servings, small amounts of toppings). When he became vegetarian he understood my disappointment and stopped eating here. We haven’t really tried much of the breakfast, though so maybe that’s good?

Oh! But I did have the weekend donuts once and those were delicious!

Updated from previous review on 2025-03-16

Pros: Local, Decent diner atmosphere , Variety of veg options

Cons: Underwhelmed by flavor and portions

squirrelboy

Points +623

Vegan
14 Nov 2024

Excellent fully featured vegan menu

I had the French toast, and it was delicious! Offers vegan breakfast and lunch/dinner food, as well as shakes.

VeganPhishPhan

Points +462

Vegan
22 Sep 2024

Average - Above Average

I ordered the Sweet Potato Hash and was a little disappointed. The Tofu Scramble part of it was pretty bland (I feel like I make a better one honestly), and the Sweet Potato Hash was weirdly sweet, like it was coated in maple syrup or something. The sweet potatos were also pretty soft and mushy - I was expecting them to be roasted or at least have some crispness to them.

I would come back and try other items off the Vegan menu, but I wouldn't order this particular item again.

I did grab a vegan brownie on the way out though, and it was ridiculously good. And huge for only $5. Could legitimately be 2-4 desserts depending on your portion sizes.

I will also give props to our server and the staff - very friendly and attentive. If you come during peak hours, expect to have to battle for parking nearby, as their lot is pretty small and fills up quick.

UPDATE (9/22/24): We went back for a birthday celebration. I got the Sheldon, which is essentially a Reuben. It was pretty good. I wish the tofu was a little more cooked. Good fries. Others in our group ordered the Shoplifters Delight and the TNT BLT, which they both enjoyed. Great service again. The waitress even let my wife pick a free dessert out of the cooler since we were celebrating her birthday. Will be back.

Updated from previous review on 2023-12-17

Pros: Staff/Service, Vegan Menu

Cons: Limited Parking, Very busy

jrehmel

Points +40

Vegan
06 Jul 2024

Vegan menu & food was so good.

We purchased:

1×Big Vegan Breakfast
$13.99
Came with potatoes, tempeh, and a scramble.

1×Vegan Burrito
$13.99
Also came with potatoes and some pico on top.

1×Vegan Sheldon
coleslaw [vegan]
$13.99
1×Vegan TNT B.L.T.
coleslaw [vegan]
$12.99

Marinated tofu sandwich and the BLT, with fried tempeh; we opted for vegan coleslaw as the sides for these since we had plenty of potatoes.

I think these are reasonable prices for what you get and all were so good.

RaeMae

Points +420

Vegan
16 Jun 2024

Breakfast Goodness!

We came to Madison from 2 hours away in order to have vegan french toast prepared for us.. we were not disappointed! Yum! Delicious french toast made with almond milk, creamy vegan butter on top, and our wonderful server made sure we had the organic, high quality maple syrup (thank you!) I had a side salad with vegan 1000 island dressing (I missed that dressing so much) and croutons and a side of hot, crispy, cooked in fresh oil french fries. Service was fast and pretty good. Thank you for offering vegan choice. We will be back just for that french toast SOON. And to have a slice of one of your 4 vegan pies. And to have shakes. Haha! No photos. It was too tasty. 💚

Updated from previous review on 2023-10-19

Pros: French toast , Cherry and Apple Pie, Vegan menu

HeatherSmithies

Points +816

Vegan
03 May 2024

Good

It was very good. I really enjoyed my sandwich.

bb.$hark

Points +2339

Vegan
16 Apr 2024

Vegan milkshake!!

I came here twice so far- the first time I got the Heathen vegan, which was okay but not my favorite. It just long of tasted burnt. But we also got a milkshake, which was actually amazing. I came here another time just to get a milkshake- they were that good. Highly recommend.

ohgeorgia

Points +1354

Vegan
06 Jan 2024

Awesome Vegan Menu

Love Monty's Blue Plate, we always stop in when we're in the area!

I love any place that gives me a whole vegan menu, and bonus points for desserts... plural! The sheldon is my favorite but I also loved the heathen vegan, and they even made me a vegan grasshopper shake when I asked. 😊

Pros: full vegan menu, vegan breakfast, friendly staff

CPederson

Points +18

Vegan
18 Oct 2023

Excellent Vegan Menu

Wonderful Vegan menu! Friendly staff! Try the HEATHEN VEGAN SHOPLIFTER'S DELIGHT
Portobellos, fried tempeh, red onions, avocado, and lemon tahini dressing on a baguette

Pros: A menu that is entirely vegan, Super friendly service, Great portions/value

rev_mlove

Points +75

Mostly Veg
06 Aug 2023

Great vegan breakfast!

This place is awesome. They have pancakes, tofu scramble, French toast, vegan shakes/ sundays and desserts. The French toast was awesome and the rhubarb strawberry pie is the best. You definitely need to be hungry!!!

Pros: Neat atmosphere , Clean, Good variety on the menu

ano

Points +192

Vegan
30 Jul 2023

Monty’s Blue Plate Diner

I love that they have a separate vegan menu, especially with so many desserts! I love the heathen vegan shoplifters delight is a great sandwich and the shakes are so good! Wish I could give it 5 stars!!

Updated from previous review on 2023-07-13

MarKey

Points +171

Vegan
04 Jul 2023

Wish I could give 5 stars!

Full separate vegan menu in the Midwest is such a hard thing to find, let alone having great food! Only thing that some may want to know, the burrito had spinach and mushrooms inside, fine by me but I know others may want to know.

Pros: Vegan menu! , Tasty, Good prices

carlaisvegan

Points +102

Vegan
16 Mar 2023

Whole vegan menu with dessert!

I had the heathen vegan shoplifter’s delight and it was very delicious and filling. It was better than any mushroom sandwich I’ve had before and they do tempeh right. They have a whole vegan menu with dessert (including pie) but I was too full to try dessert. The decor is pretty. Excellent service even when busy

Pros: whole vegan menu, vegan dessert, lots of options

izzyfrances

Points +310

Vegetarian
05 Mar 2023

So much choice for vegans

I love eating at Monty's - they have a separate vegan menu, and there's so much choice (I normally get the sweet potato hash with tofu scramble, but they have other savoury breakfast dishes, pancakes, waffles, milkshakes etc). The food is always really good, and great value for money. The service is a bit of a mixed bag, though (we've had some great servers and some not-so great).

Vancityveganeats

Points +535

Vegan
19 Feb 2023

Vegan menu!

Pleasantly surprised to see the very diverse vegan menu

Pros: Lots of vegan options , Priced well , Good portion

Cons: The tofu on the salad could’ve been seasoned bett

111artsgallery

Points +1681

Vegan
04 Jan 2023

Late night

Had shake fries and a piece pie ! Yum comfort americana food , dinner style in heart of Madison

Pros: Super tasty and great environment , Friendly service

Cons: Serves meat

BradleyDavis

Points +46

Vegan
12 Dec 2022

Lots of Vegan Options

I like this diner, lots of vegan options, not too greasy but not too health-food heavy. Vegan breakfast all day is a very good thing.

Pros: Nice diner atmosphere

Cons: No vegan butter

amandamica

Points +149

Vegan
14 Aug 2022

Separate vegan menu!

Our dinner party contained an omni, a vegetarian, and two vegans,and Monty’s had a menu to satisfy all of us! I’m a fan of the separate vegan menu so I didn’t have to search through all of their offerings. I enjoyed the Vegan Sheldon and a vegan banana shake, while my vegan partner feasted on the Vegetarian Massaman Curry (along with the rest of my shake that came on the side!). We both ate to contentment and brought home leftovers!

Updated from previous review on 2019-07-28

Pros: Lots of vegan options, Separate vegan menu, Large portion sizes




This page has been viewed 15044 times.