• Unregular Pizza - 37th St

  • (10)
    23
    Loading...
  • White Veg-options
Lacto
Pizza
Italian
Fast food
Take-out
Honey
Non-veg

Serves meat, vegan options available. Midtown branch of small pizza chain offering Roman-style pizza slices and sandwiches. Recommended to try the vegan pizza slices (margherita or mushroom). Also has a vegan spinach salad and a fried chik'n parm sandwich. Open Mon-Thu 11:00am-8:30pm, Fri 11:00am-9:00pm, Sat 11:00am-8:30pm.


Venue map for Unregular Pizza - 37th St
© OpenStreetMap contributors

10 Reviews

First Review by Poundie

JustineMasznicz

Points +426

Vegan
09 Oct 2024

Vegan pizza by the slice and more!

I came right at closing so I could only get a mushroom pizza slice—which was bomb btw. I will be coming back for their vegan chickn parm!

AnitaDollar

Points +3594

Vegan
23 Sep 2024

Yummy!

It's not the classic NYC slice, but I really enjoyed the pizza here! I only wish there were a few more varieties for vegans.

alphil

Points +429

Vegan
17 Sep 2024

Really special pizza

The pizza here is excellent and so flavoursome. We arrived very late in the evening, but luckily there was a couple of squares of pizza left. Apparently, they usually sell out of vegan options pretty quickly, so we got lucky! Definitely one to seek out. Plus the vibe inside is very retro and cool.

reese45

Points +49

Vegan
20 Aug 2024

Decent but vegan options don’t need salt

The vegan margarita was good and it was priced the same as the meat options. The vegan cheese was nothing special but it hit the spot for a quick bite.
The crust is the selling point as it was really crunchy and well cooked.
The sauce was too salty but high salt levels is something every vegan has to deal with. Tweaking the recipe to have a lot less of those would bump this up to 4 stars.

Pros: Fast, Vegan cheese, More than one vegan option

Cons: Salty, Sweet, A bit expensive for a slice

stephen808

Points +20

Vegan
03 Aug 2024

Delicious food

Only option for vegan pizza when I went in was the festa. I got the vegan chicken parm sandwich which was delicious.
Took a while to get but was worth it when it came out.

LauraBolger

Points +51

Vegan
03 Jul 2024

Best vegan pizza I've ever had!

Crispy, delicious and perfect for a quick bite in NYC. Only con is they close pretty early so at dinner time there are limited options left. I got the mushroom pizza as it was the last slice and I will be going back for more!

swizzlem12

Points +73

Vegan
23 Feb 2024

Yummy

So good I went back for a second slice. I got the vegan Margherita but there were two or three other options including a sandwich. Reasonably priced and friendly staff

croffi

Points +571

Vegan
05 Jan 2024

Delicious vegan options, reasonable prices

Unregular pizza is a great find in NYC! Two types of vegan pizza slices to choose from (Margherita and Veggie Fiesta) as well as a fully vegan chicken parm sandwich. Pizza is $5.5 and $7 respectively and a good size slice. The sandwich is $15. Will definitely be returning! #Veganuary

Pros: Reasonable prices , Good amount of sit down area, Friendly staff

Cons: More than two pizza options would be better

pphelps83

Points +105

Vegan
19 Oct 2023

Great Vegan options

Loves this place! I love the decor and the vibe and the pizza was Awesome as well. We tried the Mushroom Vegan Pizza and the Vegan Margarita, both were great but I loved the Marg. We went back a few days later and tried the Vegan Chicken Parm Sandwich, that was soooo good! Staff were friendly ask for a box so you can do the pizza bib

Pros: Vegan Options, Staff were nice, Staff were knowledgeable about the menu

Cons: they are not 100% plant based

Poundie

Points +15256

Vegan
21 Sep 2023

Top-notch vegan pizzeria slices

This branch of Unregular Pizza is much roomier than the one downtown, with a bunch of seating and an available restroom. The pizza here is great: they offer two types of vegan slices, plus a couple of other vegan items. The pizza slices are square, and have a special type of dough--and the ones here are better than or as good as other vegan slices I have found in Manhattan.

Pizza does not make for an extremely healthy meal, to be sure, but if you're gonna eat pizza, it might as well be good.

Updated from previous review on 2023-09-21

Pros: Filling, great-tasting slices, good value




This page has been viewed 1974 times.